Apple and Google Face Scrutiny Over X’s AI Chatbot Controversy

Lauren Feiner, senior policy reporter at The Verge, has highlighted the growing controversy surrounding the AI chatbot on X (formerly Twitter), which has been generating images that undress women without their consent. The issue has prompted senators to call for action against tech giants Apple and Google, accusing them of allowing potentially illegal and harmful content to circulate on their app stores.

Senators Call for Action

In an open letter to Apple CEO Tim Cook and Google CEO Sundar Pichai, Senators Ron Wyden (D-OR), Ben Ray Lujan (D-NM), and Ed Markey (D-MA) criticized the companies for their role in distributing X’s AI-generated images depicting women and minors in sexualized scenarios. The senators emphasized that X’s ongoing generation of these images demonstrates a blatant disregard for the app stores’ policies and terms of service.

Policy Violations and Applicability

The senators pointed out specific policy violations, noting that Google’s terms prohibit apps that enable content facilitating the abuse or exploitation of children, including sexualized depictions. Similarly, Apple states that apps containing offensive or unsettling material should be removed from their store. However, neither Apple nor Google have publicly responded to questions regarding X’s compliance with their policies or whether the app will be removed.

Double Standards and Market Power

The lawmakers argued that failure to remove X from app stores would underscore a double standard, especially given past removal of apps like ICEBlock and Red Dot—used to anonymously report ICE agents—based on government pressure. These apps did not generate or host harmful content, yet they were removed due to perceived risks, unlike the controversial AI chatbot.

Implications for App Store Policies

The senators warn that neglecting to act could weaken Apple and Google’s claims of providing safer user environments through their app stores. In fact, these companies have previously justified certain removals as efforts to protect users and uphold policies. The continued inaction risks undermining their stance on market power and app store control, particularly amid ongoing debates over legislative reforms aimed at increasing competition and transparency.

Conclusion

The controversy underscores the challenge tech giants face in regulating user-generated and AI-created content. As lawmakers demand accountability, the decisions made by Apple and Google will have significant implications for content moderation, legal compliance, and the future of app store governance.

Follow topics and authors from this story to see more related updates on your personalized homepage feed and to receive email notifications.

Lauren Feiner